|
Irrationality as an integral part of the transgression strategy and its potential for coping with uncertainty
DOI: 10.23951/2782-2575-2024-2-53-68
The author presents a theoretical and methodological analysis of the phenomenon of irrationality and examines its potential in the process of coping with the discomfort of uncertainty. In the paradigm of existential psychology, irrationality is presented as one of the ways of resisting uncertainty, the increasing obsolescence of individual experience in the conditions of growing awareness of the uncertainty of existence, the immaturity of modern people, and the danger of developing a fragmented identity. The article presents the idea that turning to irrationality in the process of coping with uncertainty acts as an integral part of the strategy of transgression, which can not only take the subject beyond the framework of rational cognition of reality but also provide him with new experiences of adaptation to an uncertain existence and access to the level of new possibilities or logical comprehension of reality and self-understanding (axiology, Bayesian logic, imaginative logic, logic of synchronicity). The author compares the possibilities of rational and irrational thinking and behavior in situations of uncertainty when the available experience is not sufficient, and a person who cares for himself cannot avoid making decisions and acting. The work formulates provisions on irrationality and transgression as components of the mechanisms of meaning formation and self-development.
Ключевые слова: uncertainty, precariousness, identity, experience, transgression, rationality, irrationality
Библиография:
1. Bauman Z. Tekuchaya sovremennost' [Fluid modernity]. St. Petersburg, Piter Publ., 2008: 240 p. (in Russian).
2. Belorusova E.A. Situatsiya neopredelennosti kak istochnik razvitiya [The situation of uncertainty as a source of development]. Molodoy uchenyy – Young scientist. 2018;(50 (236)):455-459 (in Russian). URL: https://moluch.ru/archive/236/54669/ (date of access: 18 January 2024).
3. Giddens E. Posledstviya sovremennosti [Consequences of modernity]. Moscow, Praksis Publ., 2011:352 p. (in Russian).
4. Lvova E.N. Lichnostnoe oposredstvovanie vybora strategiy sovladaniya v situatsii neopredelennosti [Personal mediation of the choice of coping strategies in situations of uncertainty]. Diss. PhD in Psychology. Moscow, Moscow State University named after M.V. Lomonosov Publ., 2017:290 p. (in Russian).
5. Mospan A.N. Individual’nye osobennosti psihologicheskih reakcij na situacii neopredelennosti [Individual characteristics of psychological reactions to situations of uncertainty]. Diss. Ph.D. in Psychology. Moscow, HSE Publ., 2022:147 p. (in Russian).
6. Prigozhin I. Filosofiya nestabil’nosti [Philosophy of instability]. Voprosy filosofii. 1991;(6):46-52 (in Russian).
7. Taleb N.N. Chernyy lebed’. Pod znakom nepredskazuemosti [Black Swan. Under the sign of unpredictability]. Moscow, Kolibri Publ., 2022. 736 p. (in Russian).
8. Chernavin G.I. Neponyatnost’ samo soboy razumeyushchegosya [The obscurity of the self-evident]. Saint Petersburg, Moscow, Tsentr gumanitarnykh initsiativ, Dobrosvet Publ., 2018. 244 p. (in Russian).
9. Diev V.S. Risk i neopredelennost’ v filosofii, nauke, upravlenii [Risk and uncertainty in philosophy, science, management]. Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta – Bulletin of Tomsk State University, 2011;(2 (14)):79-89 (in Russian).
10. Zotkin N.V. Smyslopolaganie v situacii neopredelennosti. Autoref. dis. kand. psihol. nauk [Making sense in situations of uncertainty. Author’s abstract. diss. PhD in Psychology]. Moscow, Institute of Preschool Education and Family Education RAO Publ., 2000:24 p. (in Russian).
11. Kornilova T.V., Chumakova M.A., Kornilov S.A., Novikova M.A. Psikhologiya neopredelennosti: Edinstvo intellektual’no-lichnostnogo potentsiala cheloveka [Psychology of uncertainty: The unity of human intellectual and personal potential]. Moscow, Smysl Publ., 2010:334 p. (in Russian).
12. Mikhina M.V. Neopredelennost’: osnovnyye kharakteristiki i opredelenie [Uncertainty: basic characteristics and definition]. Innovatsionnaya nauka – Innovative science. 2018; (5-2):140-143 (in Russian).
13. Tul’chinskiy G.L. Vozmozhnoe kak sushchee. In: Epshtein M.N. Filosofiya vozmozhnogo [Philosophy of the possible]. St. Petersburg, Aleteyya Publ., 2001:7-21 (in Russian).
14. Urmancev N.M. Neopredelennost’ bytiya i svoboda cheloveka [The uncertainty of existence and human freedom]. Vestnik Zabaykal’skogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta – Bulletin of the Transbaikal State University. 2008;(5):111-116 (in Russian).
15. Epshtein M.N. Filosofiya vozmozhnogo [Philosophy of the possible]. St. Petersburg: Aleteyya Publ., 2001:334 p.
16. Sapogova E.E. Struktura lichnostnogo tezaurusa: ekzistentsial’no-psikhologicheskiy podkhod [The structure of the personal thesaurus: an existential-psychological approach]. Sibirskiy psikhologicheskiy zhurnal – Siberian Journal of Psychology. 2019;(73):40-59 (in Russian). DOI: 10.17223/17267080/73/3
17. Klochko V.E., Klochko Yu.V. Chelovek: otkrytaya sistema v zakrytoy srede [A person: an open system in a closed environment) [Human: an open system in a closed environment]. Sibirskiy psikhologicheskiy zhurnal – Siberian journal of psychology. 2015;(57):6-16 (in Russian). DOI: 10.17223/17267080/57/1
18. Sapogova E.E. “Tekuchiy sub”ekt” v “tekuchey sovremennosti”: problemy sotsializatsii v usloviyakh neopredelennosti [“Fluid subject” in “liquid modernity”: problems of socialization under uncertainty]. Prooblemy sovremennogo obrazovaniya – Problems of modern education. 2023;(1):54-66 (in Russian). DOI: 10.31862/2218-8711-2023-1-54-66
19. Fink E. Nähe und Distanz. Phänomenologische Vorträge und Aufsätze. Freiburg; MüK.Alber, 2004:331 p.
20. Tartakovskaya I.N., Van’ke A.V. Trudovye traektorii prekarnykh rabotnikov i formirovanie prekarnogo habitusa [Mobility strategies of precarious employees and the formation of precarious habitus]. Sotsiologicheskiy Zhurnal – Sociological Journal. 2019;25(2):99-115 (in Russian). DOI: 10.19181/socjour.2019.25.2.6388
21. Standing G. Prekariat: Novyy opasnyy klass [Precariat: The New Dangerous Class]. Moscow, Ad Margin Press, 2014:328 p. (in Russian).
22. Sennet R. Korroziya kharaktera [Corrosion of character]. Novosibirsk, Fond socio-prognosticheskih issledovaniy “Trendy” Publ., 2004:296 p. (in Russian).
23. Berzonsky M. Identity formation: The role of identity processing style and cognitive processes. Personality and Individual Differences. 2008;44:645-655.
24. Breakwell G.M. Resisting representations and identity processes. Papers on Social Representations. 2010;19:6.1-6.11.
25. Castells M. The Information Age; Economy, Society and Culture. Oxford, Wiley-Blackwell, 2009:656 p.
26. Komarov S.V. Metafizika i fenomenologiya sub"ektivnosti [Metaphysics and phenomenology of subjectivity]. St. Petersburg, Aletejya, 2007:736 p. (in Russian).
27. Fuko M. Zabota o sebe. Istoriya seksual'nosti ‒ III [Self-care. History of sexuality – III]. Moscow, Grunt, 1998:282 p. (in Russian).
28. Ivanchenko G.V. Zabota o sebe. Istoriya i sovremennost’ [Self-care. History and modernity]. Moscow, Smysl Publ., 2019:304 p. (in Russian).
29. Khoroshilov D. A. Ontologicheskaya, sotsial’naya i psikhologicheskaya prekarnost’: puti vzaimodeystviya v tranzitivnom obshchestve [Ontological, social and psychological precarity: ways of interaction in a transitive society]. Novyye psikhologicheskiye issledovaniya – New Psychological Research. 2021;2:64–83 (in Russian).
30. Kemmoku A., Kuznetsova E. Bezvykhodnoye polozheniye [Hopeless position]. Vokrug sveta, 2020;(6(2957)):118–119 (in Russian).
31. Toporov V.N. Sud’ba i sluchay [Fate and chance]. In: Arutyunova N.D. (ed.) Ponyatiye sud’by v kontekste raznykh kul’tur [The concept of fate in the context of differentcultures]. Moscow, Nauka Publ., 1994:39–74 (in Russian).
32. Horoshilov D.A., Il’zher E.A. Kollektivnye perezhivaniya prekarnosti i grazhdanskie dvizheniya [Collective experiences of precarity and civic movements]. National’nyy psihologicheskiy zhurnal – National Psychological Journal. 2019;2:48-54 (in Russian). DOI: 10/11621/hpj.2019.0209
33. Beilin M.V., Kambur N.A. Prekarnost’ kak tip zhiznennoy strategii individa [Precarity as a type of individual’s life strategy]. In: Bol’shaya Evraziya: razvitie, bezopasnost’, sotrudnichestvo. Sbornik trudov V Mezhdunarodnoy nauchno-prakticheskoy konferentsii [Greater Eurasia: development, security, cooperation. Sat. Proceedings of the V International Scientific and Practical Conference]. Moscow, Institute of Scientific Information for Social Sciences of the Russian Academy of Sciences Publ., 2022:785-790 (in Russian).
34. Kormacheva I.N. Transgressiya kak mekhanizm motivatsii lichnosti [Transgression as a mechanism of personality motivation]. Chelovek v epokhu peremen. Vyzovy nastoyashchego, postroyenie budushchego. Materialy IV S"ezda psikhoterapevtov, psikhiatrov, psikhologov i konsul’tantov Sibirskogo Federal’nogo Okruga (Novosibirsk, 3–8 aprelya 2015 g.) [Man in the era of change. Challenges of the present, building the future. Materials of the IV Congress of psychotherapists, psychiatrists, psychologists and consultants of the Siberian Federal District (Novosibirsk, April 3-8, 2015)]. Novosibirsk, Novosibirsk State Technical University Publ., 2015:226-229 (in Russian).
35. Nicshe F. Chernoviki i nabroski 1885–1887 gg. [Drafts and sketches 1885–1887]. In: Nicshe F. Polnoe sobranie sochineniy v 13 t. [Complete Works. In 13 vols]. Moscow, Kul’turnaya revolyutsiya Publ., 2005;12:560 p. (in Russian).
36. Faritov V.T. Filosofskie aspekty tvorchestva M. Bakhtina: ontologiya transgressii [The Philosophical Aspects of the Work of M. Bakhtin: Transgression Ontology]. Voprosy Filosofii. 2016;(12):140-149 (in Russian).
37. Kashtanova S.M. Transgressiya kak sotsial’no-filosofskoye ponyatiye. Dis. kand. filosof. nauk [Transgression as a socio-philosophical concept]. Diss. to. Philosopher. Krasnodar, 2016:203 p. (in Russian).
38. Tarutina E. I. Obydennoye soznaniye, yego kognitivnyy i tsennostnyy aspekty [Ordinary consciousness, its cognitive and value aspects]. Vestnik AmGU ‒ AmGU Bulletin. 2010;(50):3-9 (in Russian).
39. Mekhanikova E.A. Ratsional’noye i irratsional’noye “Ya” v filosofii L.I. Shestova. Avtoref. dis. kand. filos. nauk [Rational and irrational “I” in the philosophy of L.I. Shestov. Abstract of thesis cand. philos. sci.]. Krasnodar, 2003:26 p. (in Russian).
40. Glukhareva L.I., Timina E.I. Irratsional’nost’ ratsional’nogo cheloveka [The irrationality of a rational person]. Vestnik of the Russian State Humanitarian University ‒ RSHU Bulletin. 2014;(15):18-27 (in Russian).
41. Avtonomova N.S. Rassudok, razum, racional’nost’ [Reason, intelligence, rationality]. Moscow, Nauka Publ., 1988:287 p. (in Russian).
42. Ellis A. Biologicheskoye osnovaniye chelovecheskoy irratsional’nosti [Biological basis of human irrationality]. Zhurnal prakticheskogo psikhologa. 2014;(6):133-159 (in Russian).
43. Asmolov A.G. Psikhologiya sovremennosti: vyzovy neopredelennosti, slozhnosti i raznoobraziya [Psychology of modern times: challenges of uncertainty, complexity and diversity]. Psikhologicheskiye issledovaniya – Psychological Studies. 2015;8(40):1-13 (in Russian).
44. Whitson J.A., Galinsky A.D., Kay A. The emotional roots of conspiratorial perceptions, system justification,and belief in the paranormal. Journal of Experimental Social Psuchology. 2015;56(1):89–95.
45. Orestova V.R., Tkachenko D.P., Manchkhashvili M.A. Irratsional’nost’ myshleniya kak sposob sovladaniya s neopredelennost’yu sovremennogo mira [Irrational thinking as a way of coping with the uncertainty of the modern world]. Vestnik of the Russian State Humanitarian University. Seriya: Psikhologiya. Pedagogika. Obrazovaniye ‒ RSHU Bulletin. Seriya “Psychology. Pedagogika. Education”. 2021;4:50-64 (in Russian).
46. Epshteyn M.N. Pervoponyatiya: Klyuchi k kul’turnomu kodu [First Concepts: Keys to the Cultural Code]. Moscow, KoLibri, Azbuka-Attikus Publ., 2022. 720 p. (in Russian).
47. Nagibina N.L., Artemtseva N.G. Problema ratsional’nogo i irratsional’nogo v metodologii nauchnogo poznaniya [The problem of rational and irrational in the methodology of scientificknowledge. In: Il’yasov I.I., Nagibina N.L. (eds.) Chelovek, ikusstvo, Vselennaya [Man, art, universe]. Moscow, Tsentr razvitiya cheloveka Publ., 2020:21-34 (in Russian).
48. Asmolov A.G., Gusel’tseva M. S. Psikhologiya kak remeslo sotsial’nykh izmeneniy: tekhnologii gumanizatsii i degumanizatsii v obshchestve [Psychology as a craft of social change: technologies of humanization and dehumanization in society]. Mir psikhologii – World of Psychology. 2016;(4(88)):14-28 (in Russian).
49. Ivanchenko G.V. Ponyatiye metapatologii u A. Maslou: konteksty i perspektivy [The concept of metapathology in A. Maslow: contexts and perspectives]. Psikhologiya. Zhurnal Vysshey shkoly ekonomiki – Psychology. Journal of the Higher School of Economics. 2008;5(3):105-122 (in Russian).
50. Markvard O. Epokha chuzhdosti miru? [An era of alienation to the world?]. Otechestvennyye zapiski. 2003;6 (in Russian). URL: https://magazines.gorky.media/oz/2003/6/epoha-chuzhdosti-miru.html (access date: 24 November 2023).
51. Kaneman D., Slovik P., Tverski A. Prinyatiye resheniy v neopredelennosti: pravila i predubezhdeniya [Decision making under uncertainty: rules and biases]. Kharkov, Publishing House of the Institute of Applied Psychology “Humanitarian Center”, 2005:632 p. (in Russian).
52. Tversky A., Kahneman D. Advances in project theory: Cumulative representation of uncertainty. Risk Uncertaint. 1992;(5(4)):297-323.
53. Dermanova I.B., Aleksandrova O.V., Tkachenko A.E., Kushnareva I.V. Ratsional’nyye i irratsional’nyye komponenty otsenki trudnoy zhiznennoy situatsii vzroslymi (na primere rodstvennikov detey, bol’nykh tyazhelymi i ugrozhayushchimi zhizni zabolevaniyami) [Rational and irrational components of the assessment of a difficullife situation by adults (using the example of relatives of children with serious and life-threatening diseases)]. Pediatr. 2017;8(6):118-124 (in Russian).
54. Nalimov V.V. Spontannost’ soznaniya [Spontaneity of consciousness]. Moscow, Akademicheskiy proyekt Publ., 2011:399 p. (in Russian).
55. Bryanik N.V. Voobrazhenie v traktovke klassicheskih predstavitelej evropejskoj gnoseologii [Imagination in the interpretation of classical representatives of European epistemology]. Nauchnyy yezhegodnik Instituta filosofii i prava Ural’skogo otdeleniya Rossiyskoy Akademii nauk – Scientific yearbook of the Institute of Philosophy and Law of the Ural Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences. 2015;15(3):31-46 (in Russian).
56. Toffler E. Shock budushchego[Future shock]. Moscow, AST Publ., 2002:557 p. (in Russian).
57. Vasil’ev N.A. Voobrazhaemaya logika. Izbrannye trudy [Imaginary logic. Selected works]. Moscow, Nauka Publ., 1989:264 p. (in Russian).
58. Bazhanov V.A. N.A. Vasil'ev i ego voobrazhaemaya logika. Voskreshenie odnoy zabytoy idei [N.A. Vasiliev and his imaginary logic. Resurrection of a forgotten idea]. Moscow, Kanon + ROOI “Reabilitaciya” Publ., 2009:240 p. (in Russian).
59. Golosovker Ya.E. Logika mifa [The logic of myth]. Moscow, Nauka Publ., 1987. 224 p. (in Russian).
60. Golosovker Ya.E. Imaginativnyy absolyut [Imaginative absolute]. Moscow, Akademicheskiy proyekt Publ., 2012:320 p. (in Russian).
61. Yung K.G. Sinkhroniya: akazual’nyy ob’’yedinyayushchiy printsip [Synchrony: an acausal unifying principle]. Moscow, AST Publ., 2010:352 p. (in Russian).
62. Mensfild V. Sinkhronistichnost’, nauka i sozidaniye dushi [Synchronicity, science and soul creation]. Moscow, Kastaliya Publ., 2022:332 p. (in Russian).
( 366.49 kB ) 
( 347.2 kB )
Выпуск: 2, 2024
Серия выпуска: Issue 2
Рубрика:
Страницы: 53 — 68
Скачиваний: 219